Member-only story

The Struggle Over Black Lives Matter and All Lives Matter: Rhetoric, Race, and Revolution

William Shakespeare

·5.2k Followers· Follow

Published in The Struggle Over Black Lives Matter And All Lives Matter (Rhetoric Race And Religion)

5 min read · 1 month before

123 View Claps

10 Respond

Save

Listen

The Struggle over Black Lives Matter and All Lives Matter (Rhetoric, Race, and Religion)

by Amanda Nell Edgar

4.6 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	3901 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	164 pages
Screen Reader	:	Supported

The Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement emerged in 2013 in response to the acquittal of George Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer who shot and killed Trayvon Martin, an unarmed black teenager. Since then, BLM has become a global movement, calling attention to police brutality, racial profiling, and systemic racism against black people.

The All Lives Matter (ALM) counter-movement emerged in 2015 in response to BLM. ALM supporters argue that the focus on black lives is divisive and that all lives, regardless of race, matter. They often use the slogan "All Lives Matter" to counter BLM protests and demonstrations.

The relationship between BLM and ALM is complex and often contentious. While both movements share a desire for justice and equality, their vastly different approaches and underlying ideologies have led to a deep divide that has hindered progress towards racial harmony.

Rhetorical Strategies

BLM and ALM use different rhetorical strategies to achieve their goals. BLM often uses emotional appeals, personal narratives, and statistics to highlight the lived experiences of black people in America. ALM, on the other hand, often uses logical appeals, appeals to fairness, and appeals to unity to argue that the focus on black lives is divisive.

One of the most common rhetorical strategies used by BLM is the "martyr narrative." This narrative portrays black people as innocent victims who are unjustly targeted by police and the criminal justice system. The martyr narrative is often used to evoke sympathy and outrage and to mobilize people to action.

ALM supporters, on the other hand, often use the "reverse racism" narrative. This narrative argues that the focus on black lives is discriminatory and that it creates a hierarchy of victims. The reverse racism narrative is often used to delegitimize BLM and to appeal to white people who feel threatened by the movement.

Racial Dynamics

The racial dynamics of BLM and ALM are complex and often fraught with tension. BLM is a movement that is led by and for black people. ALM, on the other hand, is a movement that is largely dominated by white people. This difference in racial composition has led to accusations of racism and white supremacy on both sides.

BLM supporters argue that ALM is a racist movement that is designed to silence and delegitimize the fight for racial justice. They point to the fact that ALM supporters often use racist rhetoric and symbols and that they have been linked to white supremacist groups.

ALM supporters, on the other hand, argue that they are not racist and that they simply believe that all lives matter. They argue that BLM is a divisive movement that focuses too much on the experiences of black people and ignores the experiences of other racial groups.

Revolutionary Potential

BLM and ALM have both been described as revolutionary movements. BLM has been credited with raising awareness of police brutality and racial injustice and with mobilizing people to action. ALM, on the other hand, has been criticized for its lack of a clear agenda and for its potential to be co-opted by white supremacists.

The long-term impact of BLM and ALM is still unknown. However, both movements have the potential to shape the future of race relations in America. BLM has the potential to bring about real change in the way that black people are treated by law enforcement and the criminal justice system. ALM, on the other hand, has the potential to divide Americans further and to derail the progress that has been made towards racial justice.

The struggle over Black Lives Matter and All Lives Matter is a complex and often contentious one. While both movements share a desire for justice and equality, their vastly different approaches and underlying ideologies have led to a deep divide that has hindered progress towards racial harmony. The long-term impact of these two movements is still unknown, but they both have the potential to shape the future of race relations in America.

The Struggle over Black Lives Matter and All Lives Matter (Rhetoric, Race, and Religion)

by Amanda Nell Edgar

4.6 out of 5